November 8, 2005
The recent announcement by Senate Judiciary Committee chairman
Arlen Specter that confirmation hearings on Judge Samuel Alito
have been postponed until January was only the latest in a series
of painful examples of what happens when Senate Republicans wimp
Senator Specter did not wimp out. The Senate Republican "leadership"
wimped out when they made him chairman of the Judiciary Committee
after he had fired a shot across the bow of his own President,
right after the election, publicly warning President Bush not
to nominate anyone to the Supreme Court who would stir up controversy
in the Senate.
That was the time to replace Senator Specter with a chairman
who would support, or at least not sabotage, the President's attempt
to put the kind of people on the courts that he had pledged to
appoint during the election campaign. Instead, the Senate "leadership"
accepted Senator Specter's assurances that he would cooperate.
Well, now he is cooperating -- with the Democrats on his committee.
The delay in Judge Alito's confirmation hearings gives the Senate
Democrats and all the liberal-left interest groups time to orchestrate
a fear and smear campaign and raise the money to advertise those
fears and smears, both directly and by organized protests that
will get much free publicity in the liberal media.
There is another aspect to this. Liberal Senators have every
incentive to drag out the confirmation process, regardless of
how the final vote turns out, because the longer they stall the
longer Sandra Day O'Connor remains on the Supreme Court. She is
their kind of judge, one who makes policy instead of applying
There was a time when the nomination of someone with Judge Alito's
high qualifications to be on the Supreme Court would be confirmed
by the Senate with little discussion and the confirmation reported
with little comment in the media. But that was in earlier times,
when common decency could be taken for granted.
Today, we can look for a Roman circus, complete with Christians
being thrown to the lions. Worse yet, the idea will be reinforced
that a judge's "views" on issues of the day are important
and need to be questioned at interminable length.
Actually, the only view that really matters is a judge's view
of the role of a judge. If a judge sees his role as applying laws
passed by other people, then his own personal views on issues
Demands for "more information" have also become part
of this Roman circus, even when the Senators themselves know that
the information they are asking for cannot be released.
If a Senator thinks the information available on any nominee
is inadequate, then all that Senator has to do is vote not to
confirm. The power to vote yes or no does not include obstructing
other Senators from voting or dragging out the confirmation hearings
into a media spectacle and a public humiliation.
Justice Clarence Thomas said it best during his confirmation hearings:
"Confirm me if you want, don't confirm me if you are so led,
but let this process end."
It needs to end for everybody -- not just for this nominee or
the next nominee but for the good of the country, so that the
best qualified people are willing to go through the nomination
process, without fear that the reputation of a lifetime will not
be dragged through the mud.
Senator Orrin Hatch has aptly said that the coming battle over
the nomination of Judge Alito will be "Armageddon."
It will be Armageddon for the Republican party.
If the Republicans are not willing to fight for the things that
people elected them to do, then some of the people who elected
them may not turn out to vote for them at the next election.
People who have for years not only voted for the Republicans,
but donated their time and money to the Republican party, who
have volunteered to stuff envelopes, man the phones and walk the
precincts to get out the vote on cold election nights, deserve
something better than Senators who wimp out at crunch time.
If the fate of the legal system in this country is not enough
incentive for Senate Republicans to show some backbone, maybe
concern for their own re-election will be.
2005 Creators Syndicate